Comparing handcrafted soap to commercial soap opens up a whole world of choices. Both options get you clean, but they do so with very different ingredients, production methods, and results. If you’re standing in the soap aisle or scrolling through handmade selections online, trying to pick between the two, this guide covers everything you need to know to make sense of your options.
Handcrafted soap draws in folks who care about natural ingredients, small batch quality, and unique scents. You’ll often find these bars packed with plant-based oils, butters, and sometimes extras like clay or oatmeal. Commercial soap, in contrast, keeps things consistent and packs a punch when it comes to affordability and shelf life. It’s widely available and usually contains more synthetic ingredients or additives to keep the price low and lather high.
If you want clear details before making the switch (or justifying your favorites), here’s a chance to jump into the main differences between handcrafted and commercial soap. Plus, get some tips about which type might match your skin and everyday routine best.
What Sets Handcrafted Soap Apart?
How It’s Made
Handcrafted soap is usually made in small batches using either the cold process or hot process method. Rather than undergoing heavy industrial processing, these bars are mixed, poured, and cured by someone who knows their craft. You can spot a handmade bar by its slightly imperfect shape, unique swirls, and eye-catching scent combinations. Makers usually skip harsh chemicals, focusing on recipes packed with nourishing oils like coconut oil, olive oil, and shea butter.
Who Will Like Handcrafted Soap?
- People with sensitive skin who want gentle, natural options
- Anyone who appreciates unique scents, artistic styles, or local makers
- Folks looking for soap without unnecessary fillers or questionable additives
Pros & Cons of Handcrafted Soap
Pros:
- Gentle on the skin thanks to natural oils and butters
- Usually free from sulfates, synthetics, and preservatives
- Supports small businesses and artisans
- A huge range of scents, colors, and formulas to explore
Cons:
- Price per bar can be quite a bit higher
- No harsh preservatives, so bars can melt away quicker in the shower
- Some varieties have a shorter shelf life
- Sizes and shapes aren’t always as uniform as big store-bought bars
Common Ingredients in Handcrafted Soap
Expect to see ingredients like olive oil, coconut oil, shea butter, cocoa butter, and essential oils. Extras might include herbs, oatmeal, activated charcoal, or clays for exfoliation. These ingredients don’t just clean. They can leave skin feeling soft, hydrated, and pampered, turning your routine into a little treat.
What Makes Commercial Soap Different?
How It’s Made
Commercial soap is produced in bulk, often using industrial machinery and formulas designed for long shelf life and consistent results. These bars typically contain detergents, preservatives, synthetic fragrances, and colorants. The focus stays on getting lots of bars out quickly and cheaply while keeping costs low. The end products always look the same on the store shelf.
Who Is Commercial Soap Best For?
- Budget-conscious shoppers who want affordable options
- Anyone who values convenience and easy availability
- Folks who enjoy strong fragrances and bright colors
Pros & Cons of Commercial Soap
Pros:
- Very affordable and easy to find everywhere
- Consistent size, scent, and lather every time
- Long shelf life thanks to added preservatives
- Plenty of options for antibacterial or deodorant bars
Cons:
- Often contains detergents or sulfates that can dry out sensitive skin
- Synthetic fragrances and dyes may irritate some people
- Less moisturizing since natural glycerin is usually removed
- May contain more ingredients that are hard to recognize or pronounce
What’s Typically Inside Commercial Soap?
Expect ingredients like sodium tallowate (animal fat), sodium lauryl sulfate (a foaming agent), synthetic fragrances, and stabilizers. Some bars add extra moisturizers or antibacterial agents, but the base tends to zero in on cleansing and producing a foamy lather.
Head-to-Head Comparison: Key Differences Explained
- Ingredients
Why It Matters: What’s in your soap impacts how your skin feels after each wash.
Handcrafted Soap: Natural oils, butters, essential oils, and usually plant-based colorants.
Commercial Soap: Plenty of synthetics, detergents, and fragrances for that consistent, bubbly experience.
Takeaway: If you’re ingredient-conscious or have sensitive skin, handcrafted soap wins this one. - Moisturizing Qualities
Why It Matters: Some soaps leave skin feeling dry, while others add moisture.
Handcrafted Soap: Retains natural glycerin, leaving your skin hydrated and soothed.
Commercial Soap: Often has glycerin removed, sometimes leaving a harsher feel.
Takeaway: Handcrafted bars usually leave your skin much softer. - Scent and Variety
Why It Matters: Some like bold synthetic fragrances; others go for gentle, natural smells.
Handcrafted Soap: Huge variety—herbal, floral, spicy, unscented.
Commercial Soap: Predictable scents and colors with fewer surprises.
Takeaway: For unique options and natural scents, handmade takes the lead. - Longevity and Storage
Why It Matters: You want your soap to stick around until the last wash.
Handcrafted Soap: Softer bars, can dissolve faster if left wet.
Commercial Soap: Crafted to last longer in wet environments due to stabilizers and hardeners.
Takeaway: Commercial soap holds up longer in the shower. - Cost and Accessibility
Why It Matters: Price adds up if you’re using soap daily.
Handcrafted Soap: Costs more per bar since it’s artisan-made.
Commercial Soap: Inexpensive and easy to find in big packs.
Takeaway: Commercial soap makes economic sense and is a quick grab.
User Experiences and Public Perception
- Handcrafted Soap: Fans rave about moisturizing effects, the feel-good factor of supporting small makers, and the fun of tracking down new formulas. A few wish it lasted longer or was easier to find everywhere.
- Commercial Soap: Most people appreciate the affordability and reliability. Some users do notice dryness, irritation, or a lack of eye-catching scents—not ideal if you want a special treat.
Overall Reputation: Handcrafted soap is popular among eco-minded buyers or those with sensitive skin. Meanwhile, commercial soap is great for buyers who put convenience and savings first.
Which Soap Should You Choose?
Both handcrafted and commercial soap wash away dirt and sweat, but what sets them apart is how much they give a boost or suit your personal needs.
Choose handcrafted soap if you:
- Have dry or sensitive skin and crave gentle ingredients
- Love supporting small businesses and enjoy artisan scents
- Prefer eco-friendly, minimal packaging options
Stick with commercial soap if you:
- Want a budget-friendly, fast purchase at the store
- Like strong scents or want antibacterial bars with a longer shelf life
- Prefer something that lasts longer in your soap dish
Picking between handcrafted and commercial soap depends on your personal preferences and what matters most for your routine. I’ve put both to work, and my favorites change depending on the season, my budget, and how my skin is feeling. If you’re curious, it’s definitely worth checking out a handmade bar or two; you might find it’s a fresh switch from the usual options that takes your daily wash up a notch.
© 2025, Tes. All rights reserved.
Really enjoyed this breakdown! I like how you made it clear there isn’t a strict “better or worse,” but more of a “what fits your lifestyle” choice. Handcrafted soap definitely feels like a self-care treat, while commercial is the practical everyday standby.
Do you think more people are starting to make the switch to handcrafted because of skin sensitivity and eco-friendly trends, or do you think commercial soap will always dominate simply because of price and convenience?
I have been selling my handmade soap for about 20 years now and I find in the last 10 years or so people are becoming more interested in natural products and more aware of what they are putting on their skin.